The People-Pleaser's Trap & How to Escape It (Part 1)

The Hidden Cost of Being “The Responsible One”

‍

When Being “Reliable” Starts Costing You More Than It Gives

You’re the one people count on. The one who handles things, solves problems, and takes ownership when others drop the ball. You take pride in showing up, in being capable. But lately, something feels off.

No matter how much you do, the appreciation never quite matches the effort. Instead of feeling respected, you feel drained. Instead of feeling valued, you feel expected. It’s not that you want to stop caring—you just don’t want to feel like you’re the only one who does.

I’ve seen this pattern play out with countless high-achievers, entrepreneurs, and professionals who push themselves hard—not because they’re weak or can’t handle pressure, but because they’ve trained themselves to carry more than they should have to. And over time, that weight starts working against them.

If any of this sounds familiar, it’s worth asking: Am I building a life where I am valued for my strengths, or one where my strengths are being taken for granted?

‍

How People-Pleasing Becomes a Productivity Trap

People-pleasers aren’t lazy. They’re the opposite—they’re often the hardest-working, most committed people in the room. But when your effort is driven by the need to be seen as dependable, rather than by what actually moves the needle in your life or business, you start mistaking over-functioning for efficiency.

Psychologists call this fawning—a response where people prioritize harmony and approval over their own well-being (Walker, 2013). It’s the same instinct that makes you say “yes” to a commitment before you’ve even had a second to ask, Is this actually necessary?

And this is where the real problem begins: when you condition others to expect you to handle everything, they stop stepping up themselves.

Studies on workplace dynamics show that the highest performers are often rewarded with more work, not necessarily more recognition (Grant, 2013). Over time, the extra effort stops feeling like a strategic choice and starts feeling like an expectation you can’t shake.

‍

The Over-Functioning Loop: How High Performers Get Stuck

Ever noticed how the moment you start carrying extra weight, people rarely ask if you want to—they just assume you will? That’s because of a psychological pattern known as the over-functioning/under-functioning dynamic (Bowen, 1978).

The more you step up, the more others step back. At first, it feels good to be seen as the “go-to” person. But soon, you realize you’re handling things that aren’t even yours to handle. And when you try to shift the load? People act like you’re the one being difficult.

Here’s how the cycle plays out:

1. You over-function – taking on tasks, solving problems, filling gaps before they’re noticed.
2. People lean on you – assuming you’ll always handle things, so they stop trying.
3. You burn out and resent it – but feel trapped because stepping back feels like dropping the ball.
4. You try to delegate or set boundaries – but others push back, confused that you’re “acting differently.”
5. Guilt makes you step back in – and the cycle starts again.

The reality? If you’re always the one stepping up, people will assume it’s by choice. If you want a different outcome, you have to shift how you show up—not just hope that people will start noticing how tired you are.

‍

“But Isn’t This Just What It Takes to Succeed?”

This is where a lot of high-performers get stuck. If you’re ambitious, driven, and care about your work, the last thing you want to hear is: “Just do less.”

And that’s not the point. The real goal isn’t to do less—it’s to do what actually matters.

Research in behavioural economics shows that people often confuse effort with effectiveness—working harder, rather than smarter (Schwartz, 2015). The problem isn’t caring—it’s that too much of your energy is going toward work that isn’t strategic, scalable, or recognized.

A study published in The Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that people often fail to notice ongoing acts of generosity because they become normalized (Flynn & Lake, 2008). In other words, the more reliable you are, the less people think to appreciate it.

So the real question isn’t Should I stop being responsible? It’s Am I being responsible in a way that serves me, too?

The First Step Toward Sustainable Success

If this resonates, the solution isn’t quitting responsibility—it’s redirecting it toward what actually moves your life forward.

Try this:

1. Pause before saying yes. Before agreeing to something, ask yourself: Is this actually necessary, or do I just feel obligated?
2. Notice where your effort goes. Are you spending energy on things that matter, or things that just maintain a dynamic where you’re the default fixer?
3. Test small shifts. Let things go. Delegate. Say no and see what happens. Not everything will fall apart the way your brain assumes it will.

Breaking this pattern isn’t about withdrawing from relationships or work—it’s about shifting your energy toward things that actually create the outcomes you want.

In Part 2, we’ll explore how people-pleasing creates invisible resentment and damages relationships—even when you think you’re just trying to help.

If you’re nodding along, take a second: When was the last time someone took care of you—without guilt? If that feels impossible, you’re overdue for a shift. Let’s talk about what’s next.